Reviews on Unearthed (2)

Add a new review

I Disliked This Book: Overly Emotional and Occasionally Irrational

Unearthed

I expected to like this book, but I did not. I found the author's extreme self-consciousness and anxiety disturbing and felt that she should avoid social media altogether since it seems to translate these into irrational aggression. Although parts of the book, particularly Mauritius's history, were certainly interesting, and I feel she has a few strong points, she pushes them too hard, too often, and sometimes, from an uninformed perspective. I feel sorry for her personal trauma. I worry about her anxiety and self-image issues, and though I sympathize with her views in places, I find her far too absolutist and not always rational, given the context: gardening.

Thought provoking read

Unearthed

Unearthed is a personal story about Claire Ratinon’s journey to feel connected to the land and her roots. Growing up in cities she felt distant from nature and unsure about where she belonged. Her life changed when she found a rooftop farm in New York which got her curious about growing food and gave her life some meaning. She left her media job and on return to London started finding food gardens and like-minded people there. She and her partner moved to the country and she started her own vegetable garden. She writes a lot about history, colonialism, racism and slavery especially related to Mauritius, her family’s home. I found the book to be very thought provoking and a few times I had to sit back and consider Claire’s point of view on the subjects of race, BLM and so on. The book was also written during the Covid year so deals with that subject as well. I enjoyed the book and enjoyed the message that we should all get back to ‘earthing’ ourselves.

1