Reviews by Andrea (42)

Interesting perspective on women in Japan and Japanese values

Butter

I enjoyed this book, but it is deeply Japanese in a way that may occasionally seem excessive - for example, a full page of people greeting each other courteously. The translation was occasionally repetitive in format. However, it proved to be an interesting book on a number of levels: the Japanese work ethic, its effects on people, particularly women, the beauty standard, and family life. I have added links to some interesting resources, including the real-life case that inspired the book. I think the perspective presented in the (rather long) video by "Salaryman" also explains Japanese work culture well, and that by understanding it, we can gain a deeper perspective on the book and its characters. In short, the book deals with a woman who is accused of serial murder and found guilty based on circumstantial evidence. Though not conventionally beautiful, she has several older "boyfriends" who fund her lifestyle in exchange for company and good food. All but one of them dies within a short timeframe, and she is accused of murdering them. The main character gains access to the woman by discussing food, and working to understand her perspective by partaking in her recommended food experiences. She writes a series of articles about the accused murderess in the runup to her appeal court case, believing she has uncovered deeper motivations that basically show she is not guilty, but that fascination with her may have led to the men neglecting themselves and dying. However, she later questions her own findings for reasons you will uncover in the book itself. Meanwhile, the story explores her relationships and background, both of which are coloured by her cultural identity. Although the tempo is slow to begin with, it builds momentum and turns out to be a very interesting read. The real-life inspiration for this story is also of interest, and I have posted a link that explains it.

I Struggled With This Book and Disliked a Lot of Things About It

Blood's Inner Rhyme

This book is a pastiche of events, old letters, newer letters, and carer notes. I think including the latter is iffy. Yes, we keep notes about confused mental states, bowel movements, and bed wettings, so that when one carer hands over to another, they know what the patient's condition is. I don't think these notes should be published. There's also quite a focus on the Boer War and women's experiences in the conflict zone. War is never nice, but this exhumation of history was disturbing on many levels. It also reminded me of the conflicts - even among Afrikaners, that I grew up with: whose grandparents were "Hanskakies" (Afrikaans supporters of the English) in the Boer War, Verwoerd lovers and haters, who supported Hitler in the Second World War and who didn't, who talked to whom, who didn't, and so on. Perhaps people with more distance from the subject matter might enjoy it more. I found the jumping around confusing, the focus on the Boer War unnecessary, and the reverence for Verwoerd, plus the publication of care worker notes, distasteful. I gave up halfway. Yes, both Krog and her mother are accomplished women, but I don't like the book. I respected it and didn't throw it against the wall, but that's as far as it goes.

A Fun, Light Read

Holmes and Moriarty

Definitely not high literature. Perfect for B-grade horror and unbelievable enough to be funny rather than scary. There isn't much else I can say about it other than noting that, although I enjoyed it, it's not the kind of book I'd bother to read twice.

1 2 ... 9